The gourmet cookie market has exploded in recent years, transforming what was once a simple baked good into a premium dessert experience worthy of social media posts and dedicated fan communities. Two brands have emerged as dominant players in this space: Crumbl Cookies, with its viral weekly rotating menu and distinctive pink boxes, and Twisted Sugar, the challenger brand offering a different take on the premium cookie concept.

For consumers faced with choosing between these two options—or food enthusiasts curious about how they stack up—this comprehensive comparison examines every aspect from taste and texture to pricing and overall experience.

Introduction: The Rise of the Gourmet Cookie Wars

Brief History and Foundational Concept (Origin Stories)

Crumbl Cookies launched in 2017 in Logan, Utah, founded by cousins Sawyer Hemsley and Jason McGowan. The brand’s origin story centers on a quest to perfect the chocolate chip cookie, which evolved into a revolutionary business model: the weekly rotating menu. This approach transformed cookies from a commodity into an event, with customers eagerly anticipating each Sunday evening’s menu announcement. The franchise model accelerated growth exponentially, reaching over 900 locations by 2024 and becoming one of the fastest-growing food franchises in American history.

Twisted Sugar emerged from Utah as well, founded in 2018—just a year after Crumbl. Created by Kylee and Jared Openshaw, Twisted Sugar positioned itself as an alternative to the increasingly ubiquitous Crumbl experience. Rather than focusing solely on weekly rotation and cookie size, Twisted Sugar emphasized a broader dessert experience, incorporating gourmet sodas (including the trendy “dirty soda” concept popular in Utah), customizable cookie options, and a more stable menu that doesn’t completely change every week. The brand has grown more conservatively, with approximately 60-80 locations as of 2024, maintaining a more regional presence primarily in the Western United States.

Both brands emerged from Utah’s thriving dessert culture and Mormon community, where soda shops and sweet treats have particular cultural significance due to religious restrictions on alcohol and coffee consumption.

Key Differentiators at a Glance

Feature	Crumbl	Twisted Sugar
Founded	2017	2018
Locations	900+ nationwide	60-80 (primarily Western US)
Cookie Size	4-6 oz (oversized)	3-4 oz (large but smaller)
Menu Style	Weekly rotating (4 new flavors)	Stable core menu with seasonal additions
Price Range	$4.50-$5.50 per cookie	$3.50-$4.50 per cookie
Serving Temp	Warm/room temp	Often chilled/room temp
Signature Feature	Pink boxes, weekly rotation	Gourmet sodas, toppings bar
Beyond Cookies	Ice cream only	Sodas, shakes, cookie cups, milk
Branding	Bold pink, social media-focused	Softer pastels, community-focused

Product Deep Dive: Taste, Texture, and Temperature

Crumbl’s Signature Style

Size and Presentation

Crumbl’s most immediately recognizable feature is sheer size. Each cookie weighs approximately 4-6 ounces—roughly four times larger than a standard bakery cookie. This creates an impressive visual impact and positions the product as shareable (though many customers eat them solo).

The presentation is equally distinctive. Crumbl’s bright pink boxes have become cultural icons, instantly recognizable on social media and in-person. The packaging is designed for Instagram appeal, with cookies arranged in a way that showcases their generous size and elaborate toppings.

The open kitchen concept allows customers to watch cookies being mixed, baked, and decorated in real-time, creating transparency and theater around the production process.

Texture and Served Temperature

Crumbl cookies are typically served warm or at room temperature, with many varieties benefiting from a 15-30 second microwave reheat. The brand’s signature texture leans toward soft and slightly underbaked—cookies have crispy edges but maintain a gooey, almost molten center.

This texture profile divides opinion. Fans appreciate the indulgent, fresh-from-the-oven quality. Critics sometimes find the cookies underbaked or too soft, lacking the structural integrity some prefer in a cookie.

The brand has expanded beyond traditional cookies to include chilled dessert cups (marked “NCD” – Not a Cookie, Dude) and cake-style cookies that require refrigeration, adding textural variety to the menu.

Flavor Philosophy

The weekly rotating menu is Crumbl’s defining characteristic. Every Sunday at 8:00 PM, four new specialty flavors launch alongside two permanent classics (Milk Chocolate Chip and Chilled Sugar Cookie). This creates constant novelty and urgency—if you love a flavor, you have only six days to enjoy it before it potentially disappears for months.

Flavors range from classic (chocolate chip variations) to adventurous (Biscoff Lava, Raspberry Cheesecake, French Silk Pie). The rotation keeps the brand feeling fresh and encourages repeat visits from customers curious about new offerings.

However, this model has drawbacks: favorite flavors may not return frequently, and the quality of weekly offerings varies significantly. Some rotations feature universally beloved options, while others include experimental flavors that divide customers.

Twisted Sugar’s Approach

Size and Presentation

Twisted Sugar cookies are large but noticeably smaller than Crumbl’s offerings—typically 3-4 ounces compared to Crumbl’s 4-6 ounces. This smaller size makes them more reasonable for individual consumption while still feeling premium compared to standard bakery cookies.

Presentation emphasizes toppings and decoration. Twisted Sugar cookies often feature elaborate drizzles, frosting swirls, candy pieces, and creative garnishes that create visual appeal. The cookies are frequently individually wrapped, making them convenient for on-the-go consumption or gifting.

The store aesthetic uses softer pastel colors rather than Crumbl’s bold pink, creating a different visual identity that feels less aggressively branded and more boutique-like.

Texture and Served Temperature

Twisted Sugar cookies are often served chilled or at room temperature, with many varieties featuring cream cheese frosting or delicate toppings that benefit from cooler temperatures. The texture tends toward slightly firmer and more structured than Crumbl’s soft-baked style.

This creates a different eating experience—Twisted Sugar cookies feel more like traditional bakery cookies with gourmet toppings, while Crumbl cookies are softer and more cake-like in many cases.

The chilled serving temperature works particularly well for frosted varieties, preventing melting and maintaining the integrity of elaborate decorations.

Flavor Philosophy

Unlike Crumbl’s complete weekly overhaul, Twisted Sugar maintains a core menu of popular flavors available consistently, with seasonal additions and limited-time offerings rotating in. This approach has advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages: Customers can return for favorite flavors reliably. No FOMO (fear of missing out) pressure. New visitors can try the “greatest hits” rather than whatever happens to be in that week’s rotation.

Disadvantages: Less novelty and excitement. Fewer reasons for frequent repeat visits since the menu remains largely stable.

Popular permanent flavors include variations of chocolate chip, sugar cookies with elaborate frosting, and specialty options like cookie dough-stuffed cookies. The menu typically features 8-12 options at any given time, providing more immediate choice than Crumbl’s six weekly options.

Pricing and Value Analysis

Cost Per Cookie Comparison

Crumbl pricing:

• Single cookie: $4.50-$5.50 (market dependent)
• 4-pack: $16-$20 ($4-5 per cookie)
• 6-pack: $24-$28 ($4-4.67 per cookie)
• 12-pack: $45-$55 ($3.75-4.58 per cookie)

Twisted Sugar pricing:

• Single cookie: $3.50-$4.50
• 4-pack: $14-$16 ($3.50-4 per cookie)
• 6-pack: $20-$24 ($3.33-4 per cookie)
• 12-pack: $38-$45 ($3.17-3.75 per cookie)

On a per-cookie basis, Twisted Sugar is consistently $1-1.50 cheaper than Crumbl across all package sizes. However, Crumbl’s cookies are also noticeably larger, complicating direct price comparison.

Box Pricing and Bulk Discounts

Both brands offer volume discounts that make larger boxes more economical per cookie. The savings increase with size—a 12-pack provides approximately 15-20% savings per cookie compared to individual purchases at both chains.

For parties or events, this makes bulk purchasing significantly more cost-effective. A 12-pack from Twisted Sugar might cost $40-45 compared to $50-55 at Crumbl, representing $10-15 in savings for similar cookie counts.

However, Crumbl’s larger individual cookie size means that while you might get fewer cookies for your money, you’re getting more total cookie weight and potentially more servings if sharing.

Determining Overall Value

Value assessment depends on what you prioritize:

Crumbl offers better value if you prioritize:

• Maximum size (more cookie per dollar when comparing weight)
• Social media appeal and presentation
• Weekly variety and novelty
• Shareable portions (one cookie feeds 2-4 people)

Twisted Sugar offers better value if you prioritize:

• Lower absolute cost
• Individual-sized portions
• Reliable access to favorite flavors
• Additional beverage options included in your visit

Ingredient quality is comparable between brands—both use real butter, quality chocolate, and premium ingredients. Neither is using inferior components that would justify a significant price difference based on quality alone.

The “value” winner ultimately depends on whether you value size and novelty (Crumbl) or price and consistency (Twisted Sugar).

Menu Variety Beyond Cookies

Crumbl’s Focused Menu

Crumbl maintains a laser focus on cookies, with ice cream as the only significant menu addition. This specialization has advantages—the brand has perfected cookie production and can maintain consistent quality by not diversifying too broadly.

The ice cream offerings are limited, typically featuring a few flavors that can be purchased by the scoop or pint. Some locations offer ice cream sandwiches using the weekly cookie flavors, creating a hybrid product.

This narrow menu means Crumbl is a single-purpose destination. You visit specifically for cookies, not as a broader dessert or beverage experience.

Twisted Sugar’s Expanded Offerings

Twisted Sugar positions itself as more than a cookie shop, offering a comprehensive dessert experience:

Cookie cups: Smaller cookie portions served in cups with ice cream, creating a cookie sundae hybrid.

Gourmet sodas: A full soda bar with customizable drinks, including the trendy “dirty soda” concept.

Flavored milk: Premium milk options that pair with cookies.

Seasonal beverages: Hot chocolate, specialty drinks that change with seasons.

This diversified menu creates multiple revenue streams and gives customers reasons to visit beyond cookie purchases alone.

The Significance of “Dirty Soda” in the Twisted Sugar Model

“Dirty soda” refers to soda mixed with cream, flavored syrups, and sometimes fruit purees—a trend that emerged from Utah’s soda shop culture. Twisted Sugar has embraced this concept, offering elaborate customizable soda creations that have become signature items in their own right.

For customers, this means Twisted Sugar functions as both a cookie destination and a beverage spot, similar to how coffee shops serve both coffee and food. The soda offerings have significant margins and encourage customers to increase their per-visit spending beyond just cookies.

This positions Twisted Sugar more as a “dessert café” while Crumbl remains a “cookie bakery,” creating differentiated experiences despite similar core products.

Store Experience, Branding, and Aesthetics

Crumbl’s Digital and Physical Presence

Crumbl has invested heavily in creating a distinctive, social media-optimized experience:

The app: Crumbl’s mobile app is central to the experience, allowing menu browsing, ordering, curbside pickup, and loyalty rewards. The Sunday evening menu drop happens first on the app, creating anticipation and driving downloads.

Open kitchen: The transparent production process lets customers watch cookies being made, creating entertainment and trust in freshness.

Pink branding: The aggressive use of bright pink creates instant brand recognition but also creates a love-it-or-hate-it aesthetic response.

Social media integration: Everything about Crumbl is optimized for Instagram and TikTok—the large cookies photograph well, the pink boxes are distinctive, and the weekly menu changes create constant content opportunities.

Efficiency focus: The store layout and processes prioritize speed and throughput, with most customers in and out within minutes.

Twisted Sugar’s Ambiance

Twisted Sugar stores typically feature:

Community atmosphere: More seating, a slower pace, and encouragement to linger rather than grab-and-go.

Softer aesthetic: Pastel colors, less aggressive branding, a more boutique feel compared to Crumbl’s chain uniformity.

Customization focus: The soda bar and toppings create an interactive experience where customers can personalize orders.

Local integration: More emphasis on feeling like a local gathering spot rather than a nationwide brand.

This creates a different vibe—Twisted Sugar feels more like a neighborhood dessert café, while Crumbl feels more like a streamlined cookie factory with viral appeal.

Ordering Process and Efficiency

Crumbl:

• Heavy emphasis on app ordering
• Curbside pickup widely available
• Delivery through app and third-party services
• Process optimized for speed and volume
• Limited in-store customization

Twisted Sugar:

• Mix of in-store ordering and app ordering
• More in-store interaction due to soda customization
• Delivery available but less emphasized
• Process allows for more personalization
• Staff interaction higher due to custom orders

For customers seeking maximum efficiency, Crumbl’s streamlined app-first approach wins. For those wanting a more personalized, interactive experience, Twisted Sugar’s model provides more engagement.

Accessibility and National Footprint

Franchise Growth and Market Saturation of Crumbl

With 900+ locations, Crumbl has achieved remarkable geographic penetration. Most major metropolitan areas and many mid-sized cities now have at least one Crumbl location, with some markets featuring multiple stores.

This rapid expansion creates:

Advantages: High likelihood of finding a Crumbl near you, consistent experience across locations, brand recognition.

Disadvantages: Market oversaturation in some areas (multiple stores competing for the same customers), franchise quality variations, occasional closures as unprofitable locations shut down.

Crumbl’s franchise model prioritizes rapid territory filling, which has driven growth but also led to some markets becoming oversaturated, contributing to the store closures discussed in broader franchise analysis.

Regional Focus and Expansion Strategy of Twisted Sugar

Twisted Sugar’s 60-80 locations concentrate primarily in:

• Utah (home market with highest density)
• Nevada
• Arizona
• Idaho
• Texas (growing presence)
• California (selective markets)

This regional focus allows for:

Advantages: Better quality control with slower growth, stronger brand identity in core markets, less cannibalization between locations.

Disadvantages: Most of the country cannot access Twisted Sugar, limiting growth potential and brand awareness.

Twisted Sugar appears to be pursuing a more conservative expansion strategy, focusing on market establishment before aggressive growth. This may prevent some of the franchise challenges Crumbl has faced, but also limits the brand’s reach.

Who You Are More Likely to Find in Your City

If you live in: A major metropolitan area (New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Miami, Dallas, etc.), you almost certainly have access to Crumbl and probably don’t have Twisted Sugar.

If you live in: The Mountain West or Southwest (Utah, Arizona, Nevada, parts of Texas), you likely have access to both brands.

If you live in: Rural areas or smaller cities, you may have neither, though Crumbl’s rapid expansion makes it more likely to arrive first.

For most American consumers, Crumbl is the accessible option simply due to geographic availability. Twisted Sugar remains a regional brand that many consumers outside the Western US have never encountered.

The Final Verdict: Which Cookie is Right for You?

When to Choose Crumbl

Choose Crumbl if you value:

Novelty and variety: The weekly rotation ensures you’ll never be bored and always have new flavors to try.

Size and shareability: The oversized cookies work well for sharing with family or bringing to gatherings where one cookie can serve multiple people.

Social media appeal: If you’re posting your desserts on Instagram or TikTok, Crumbl’s distinctive presentation and brand recognition provide superior social currency.

Convenience and accessibility: With 900+ locations, Crumbl is simply easier to find for most Americans.

The “event” experience: The Sunday menu drop, the anticipation of favorite flavors returning, and the FOMO element create an experiential aspect beyond just eating cookies.

App-first ordering: If you prefer minimal human interaction and maximum efficiency, Crumbl’s optimized app experience excels.

When to Choose Twisted Sugar

Choose Twisted Sugar if you value:

Consistent favorites: If you find a flavor you love, you can return for it reliably rather than waiting for it to reappear in rotation.

Price sensitivity: The $1-1.50 per cookie savings adds up, especially for families or frequent visitors.

Individual-sized portions: If you want a single cookie that’s substantial but not overwhelming, Twisted Sugar’s sizing is more appropriate.

Broader menu options: The gourmet sodas, cookie cups, and beverage menu create a more complete dessert café experience.

Community atmosphere: The slower pace, more seating, and encouragement to linger create a different social experience.

Less aggressive branding: If Crumbl’s bold pink aesthetic and social media focus feel too corporate or trendy, Twisted Sugar’s softer approach may appeal more.

Overall Recommendation Summary

There is no definitive winner—each brand excels in different areas.

Crumbl dominates in: Size, novelty, brand recognition, accessibility, and social media appeal. It’s the better choice for special occasions, gifts, parties, and when you want the “full experience” of participating in the weekly flavor culture.

Twisted Sugar excels in: Price, menu consistency, beverage options, and creating a neighborhood dessert café atmosphere. It’s the better choice for regular visits, families watching budgets, and anyone who wants reliable favorites alongside their cookie purchase.

For most consumers, the decision comes down to availability. If both options exist in your market, trying both and developing personal preferences makes sense. If only one is available, you’re likely to be satisfied with whichever you can access—both produce quality gourmet cookies that significantly exceed grocery store or standard bakery options.

Ideal scenario: Visit Crumbl when you want to participate in the weekly flavor excitement or need impressive presentation for an event. Visit Twisted Sugar when you want a reliable treat with a beverage on a more regular basis. Use each brand for its strengths rather than expecting one to fulfill all cookie needs.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Twisted Sugar and Crumbl owned by the same company?

No, Twisted Sugar and Crumbl are completely separate companies with different ownership structures. Crumbl Cookies was founded by Sawyer Hemsley and Jason McGowan in 2017, while Twisted Sugar was founded by Kylee and Jared Openshaw in 2018.

While both brands originated in Utah and share some cultural DNA from the region’s dessert scene, they are independent competitors in the gourmet cookie space. There is no corporate relationship, shared ownership, or business partnership between the two companies.

The confusion sometimes arises because both emerged from Utah around the same time and target similar demographics, but they operate as direct competitors rather than related brands.

Which cookie is bigger: Crumbl or Twisted Sugar?

Crumbl cookies are significantly larger than Twisted Sugar cookies. Crumbl cookies typically weigh 4-6 ounces each, while Twisted Sugar cookies weigh approximately 3-4 ounces.

To put this in perspective, a Crumbl cookie is roughly the size of a small plate and is often marketed as shareable (serving 2-4 people). A Twisted Sugar cookie is still large compared to standard bakery cookies but is more reasonably sized for individual consumption.

This size difference is one of Crumbl’s most distinctive features and part of what justifies their higher price point. When comparing cost per ounce of cookie, the price gap between the brands narrows considerably, though Twisted Sugar typically still offers slightly better value even when accounting for size differences.

The larger size isn’t necessarily better or worse—it depends on your needs. Crumbl’s size works well for sharing or creating an impressive presentation, while Twisted Sugar’s size is more practical for enjoying a complete cookie yourself without feeling overwhelmed.

Which company has the wider flavor selection over the course of a year?

This depends on how you define “wider selection.”

In terms of total different flavors offered annually: Crumbl offers substantially more variety. With four new flavors every week (plus seasonal variations), Crumbl introduces approximately 200+ different flavors per year. Even accounting for some repeats and fan-favorite returns, customers experience significantly more distinct flavors over a year at Crumbl.

In terms of immediate choice on any given visit: Twisted Sugar typically offers more options. While Crumbl provides exactly six choices each week (four rotating plus two permanent), Twisted Sugar usually features 8-12 flavors available simultaneously, giving you more decision-making options during a single visit.

In terms of accessing favorite flavors: Twisted Sugar provides more reliable access. Their core menu remains stable, so if you discover a flavor you love, you can return for it consistently. With Crumbl, favorite flavors may only appear once or twice per year, and there’s no guaranteed schedule for when they’ll return.

For variety seekers who enjoy constant novelty, Crumbl’s approach provides more experiences over time. For customers who prefer having their favorites available reliably, Twisted Sugar’s stable menu with seasonal additions works better.

Is Twisted Sugar cheaper than Crumbl?

Yes, Twisted Sugar is consistently cheaper than Crumbl across all purchasing options.

Price comparison:

• Single cookies: Twisted Sugar is typically $1-1.50 less per cookie
• 4-packs: Twisted Sugar averages $2-4 less per box
• 6-packs: Twisted Sugar averages $4-6 less per box
• 12-packs: Twisted Sugar averages $7-10 less per box

For example, a 6-pack at Twisted Sugar might cost $20-24, while the same 6-pack at Crumbl costs $24-28.

Important context: Crumbl cookies are larger (4-6 oz vs. 3-4 oz), so part of the price difference reflects the size difference. When calculating price per ounce, the gap narrows but Twisted Sugar typically still offers 10-20% better value even accounting for size.

For budget-conscious consumers or families making regular cookie purchases, Twisted Sugar’s lower prices can result in significant savings over time. However, if you’re prioritizing size, presentation, or the specific Crumbl experience, the premium pricing may be justified for your purposes.

Does Twisted Sugar offer delivery?

Yes, Twisted Sugar offers delivery, though the options and availability vary by location.

Delivery methods:

1. Third-party services: Most Twisted Sugar locations partner with DoorDash, Uber Eats, and sometimes Grubhub for delivery. Availability depends on your specific location and distance from the store.
2. In-house delivery: Some locations offer their own delivery service through phone orders or online ordering, though this is less common than third-party partnerships.
3. Delivery radius: Typical delivery radius is 3-5 miles from the store location, similar to most dessert establishments.

Important differences from Crumbl: Twisted Sugar has not invested as heavily in delivery infrastructure and app development as Crumbl. The Crumbl app makes delivery ordering seamless and central to the experience, while Twisted Sugar relies more on third-party services and has a less developed proprietary ordering system.

For the most reliable delivery information, check your preferred delivery app (DoorDash, Uber Eats) to see if your local Twisted Sugar appears, or call the specific store directly to ask about delivery options. Availability can vary significantly between different Twisted Sugar franchise locations.